Revenue Share is now live! Enroll to earn 50% of Hord fees

Arrow go backTelegramTwitterWhatsappFacebook

What is an Ethereum ETF

Jon Ganor
Jon Ganor
What is an Ethereum ETF
Arrow go back

tl;dr

  • An ETF is a financial instrument that pools together assets like stocks, bonds, or commodities into a single investment product
  • Ethereum ETFs come in two main types: futures ETFs and spot ETFs.

  • ETH Futures ETFs track futures contracts linked to ETH's price, allowing investors to speculate on the future price of Ethereum without directly holding the cryptocurrency.

  • Spot ETH ETFs directly hold Ethereum and offer investors a more direct way to invest in Ethereum by holding actual ETH, similar to how a gold ETF holds physical gold.

  • Key differences between investing in a spot ETH ETF and owning ETH tokens include the investment process, regulation, trading hours, fees, and security.

  • Benefits of the spot ETH ETF include easier buying and selling and potential security advantages from custodial services.

What is an ETF?

An Exchange Traded Fund or ETF is a financial instrument that pools together assets like stocks, bonds, or commodities into a single investment product. Think of it as a basket that holds various investments, allowing investors to access diversified exposure to multiple assets through a single transaction.

ETFs operate similarly to mutual funds in that they offer diversification benefits by spreading risk across different securities. However, ETFs differ in their trading mechanism. While mutual funds are priced once a day after the market closes, ETFs trade continuously throughout the trading day on stock exchanges, just like individual stocks. This means investors can buy or sell ETF shares at any time during market hours, providing flexibility and liquidity.

ETFs come in various types, each designed to meet different investment objectives and strategies. For example, some ETFs track specific market indexes like the S&P 500, providing investors with broad market exposure. Others focus on particular sectors such as technology, healthcare, or energy, allowing investors to target specific industries. There are also ETFs that invest in bonds, commodities like gold or oil, and even alternative assets like cryptocurrencies.

Investors can choose ETFs based on their investment goals, risk tolerance, and market outlook. The transparency, liquidity, and diversification benefits offered by ETFs have made them popular investment vehicles for both retail and institutional investors seeking efficient and cost-effective ways to build diversified portfolios and gain exposure to various asset classes.

What are ETH ETFs?

Ethereum ETFs come in two main types: futures ETFs and spot ETFs.

ETH Futures ETFs

Futures ETFs for Ethereum were launched in the US in October 2023. These ETFs do not directly hold Ethereum itself but instead track futures contracts linked to ETH's price. Futures contracts are agreements to buy or sell an asset at a specific price on a certain date in the future. Notable asset managers like VanEck and Bitwise filed for these futures ETFs in mid-2023. Futures ETFs allow investors to speculate on the future price of Ethereum without directly holding the cryptocurrency.

Spot ETH ETFs

Spot Ethereum ETFs directly hold Ethereum and are not yet approved by the US Securities and Exchange Commission aka the SEC. These ETFs would offer investors a more direct way to invest in Ethereum by holding actual ETH, similar to how a gold ETF holds physical gold. Spot ETFs are generally viewed as more desirable than futures ETFs due to potentially lower fees and a direct tie to the underlying asset.

Several firms, including Fidelity, have filed for spot Ethereum ETFs, but the SEC has been cautious about approving them. The SEC's concerns revolve around potential market manipulation and volatility in the cryptocurrency market. Despite the growing interest in spot ETFs for Ethereum, regulatory hurdles remain a significant barrier to their approval in the US. Nonetheless, the introduction of futures ETFs for Ethereum marks a significant development in the cryptocurrency investment landscape, providing investors with alternative ways to gain exposure to ETH's price movements.

Key Differences Between Investing in a Spot ETH ETF & ETH 

Investing in a spot Ethereum ETF and directly owning ETH tokens involve several key differences. The spot ETH ETF holds actual Ethereum in its reserves to track its price directly while owning ETH means you directly own the Ethereum tokens yourself. The investment process differs as well: for the spot ETH ETF, you buy and sell shares of the ETF on a stock exchange, similar to buying a stock; owning ETH requires setting up a crypto wallet and buying ETH through a cryptocurrency exchange.

Regulation plays a role too. The spot ETH ETF is regulated by financial authorities like the SEC, offering potential investor protection benefits, whereas ETH itself is largely unregulated, offering less investor protection compared to ETFs. Trading hours also vary, with the spot ETH ETF trading during regular stock market hours and ETH trading available 24/7 in crypto markets.

Fees differ as well, with the spot ETH ETF potentially having higher fees due to expense ratios, while ETH involves transaction fees on cryptocurrency exchanges. Security is another aspect, with the spot ETH ETF provider holding the Ethereum in secure custody, potentially reducing individual loss risk from hacks, compared to ETH where you are responsible for securing your own cryptocurrency wallet.

Benefits of the spot ETH ETF include easier buying and selling and potential security advantages from custodial services, while benefits of owning ETH include 24/7 trading, potentially lower fees, and direct control over your assets. Overall, the choice depends on factors like convenience, security preferences, regulation, and trading flexibility.

Chances of the SEC’s Approval of an ETH ETF

The chances of the SEC approving an ETH ETF are uncertain. Many anticipate approval by 2024 or 2025, due to the recent approval of spot Bitcoin ETFs. However, recent SEC comments hinting at Ethereum classification as a security may delay this possibility. 

Regulatory considerations and evolving SEC stances will likely impact the timeline for the likely ETH ETF approval.

The Risks & Benefits of an ETH ETF

Investing in an ETH ETF comes with both benefits and risks. On the positive side, an ETH ETF provides easier access to Ethereum for traditional investors who may not be familiar with cryptocurrency exchanges. It follows a traditional investment style, trading on stock exchanges like regular stocks.

Regulation and investor protection are potential benefits of an ETH ETF, as they are regulated by financial bodies, offering a level of security compared to the less regulated crypto market. Additionally, ETFs allow for diversification by holding a basket of assets, potentially reducing risk by spreading investments.

High liquidity is another advantage, making it easier to buy and sell ETF shares compared to the sometimes less liquid crypto markets.

However, there are risks associated with ETH ETFs. These include tracking errors, where the ETF price may not perfectly mirror the underlying ETH price due to fees and structure. Counterparty risk is also a concern, as there's a risk that the entity holding the ETH for the ETF could default.

ETFs may also have limited functionality compared to owning ETH directly, such as the inability to participate in staking for earning rewards. Higher fees are another consideration, as management fees can impact returns compared to direct ETH ownership. Regulatory uncertainty is a significant risk, as future regulations could affect the value and viability of ETH ETFs.

Bitcoin ETF vs Ethereum ETF

Choosing between a Bitcoin ETF and an Ethereum ETF depends on individual investment goals and risk tolerance. Bitcoin offers established recognition and potential stability, often seen as a store of value akin to gold, while Ethereum presents greater growth potential due to its role in decentralized applications and smart contracts.

Bitcoin's pros include its establishment as the first cryptocurrency and its perceived stability against inflation. However, its growth potential may be limited compared to Ethereum, which is more versatile and functional beyond being a store of value.

Ethereum's strengths lie in its potential for rapid growth, given its involvement in dApps and smart contracts. It offers broader utility but comes with higher volatility and is still evolving technologically compared to Bitcoin.

Consider your investment goals and assess your risk tolerance, as Ethereum's price swings can be more pronounced.

Regulation is another factor; while Bitcoin ETFs are available, spot ETH ETFs are pending approval in the US as of April 2024, with only futures ETFs currently accessible, which may add complexity to investment strategies.

What Could Happen to ETH After an ETH ETF is Approved?

The approval of an ETH ETF could have several potential impacts on Ethereum and its market dynamics. Firstly, increased demand for ETH is anticipated, particularly from institutional investors who find it more accessible through ETFs. This surge in demand could lead to a corresponding increase in the price of ETH, similar to the effect observed with Bitcoin after the approval of Bitcoin ETFs.

Moreover, the approval of an ETH ETF could contribute to legitimizing the Ethereum blockchain and its ecosystem in the eyes of traditional finance. This legitimization could attract more mainstream investors and developers to Ethereum, further enhancing its value proposition and market standing.

Additionally, ETFs generally trade with high liquidity, providing easier access for investors to buy and sell shares. This increased liquidity could spill over into the broader ETH market, potentially reducing price volatility over time as trading becomes more efficient and liquid.

However, it's important to note that these potential impacts are speculative, and the actual outcome post-ETF approval may vary based on market conditions.

Final Thoughts from Jon Ganor

An ETH ETF approval appears to be a matter of when, not if, given the precedent set by Bitcoin ETFs. Such approval could significantly boost ETH's price, similar to Bitcoin's experience, by increasing accessibility to institutional investors and enhancing market legitimacy. This potential surge in demand, coupled with improved liquidity and investor confidence, could contribute to a price rally for the entire cryptocurrency ecosystem upon ETF approval.

FAQs

Will an ETH ETF be Approved?

The approval of a spot Ethereum ETF seems likely given the precedent set by Bitcoin ETF approvals. However, the exact date of approval remains uncertain and depends on regulatory considerations and market conditions.

How can I Invest in an ETH ETF?

As of now, since an ETH ETF has not been approved by the SEC, you cannot directly invest in an ETH ETF. However, you can monitor developments in the regulatory landscape and stay informed about any updates regarding ETH ETF approvals. Once an ETH ETF is approved and available for investment, you can explore options through traditional brokerage accounts or investment platforms that offer access to ETFs.

What are the Fees for Investing in ETH ETF?

The fees for investing in an ETH ETF can vary depending on the specific ETF provider and the type of ETF. Generally, ETFs may charge management fees, also known as expense ratios, which cover the costs of managing the ETF, including administrative expenses, marketing, and operational costs. These fees are typically expressed as a percentage of the total assets under management or AUM and are deducted from the ETF's returns.

In addition to management fees, there may be other costs associated with investing in ETFs, such as trading commissions, bid-ask spreads (the difference between buying and selling prices), and potential taxes on capital gains.

Is the ETH ETF Safe?

The safety of investing in an ETH ETF versus holding ETH directly depends on factors such as regulatory oversight, custody arrangements, investor knowledge and experience, and risk tolerance. For most investors not involved in the world of cryptocurrencies, an ETF may be a great choice. 

Can you Lose Money Investing in an ETH ETF? 

Yes, it's possible to lose money investing in an ETH ETF, just as with any investment.